News 
 Local News 
 News 
 Rural 
 Worse to come from live export ban fiasco 

Worse to come from live export ban fiasco

27 Jul, 2011 09:12 AM
A NORTHERN Territory vet says Australia will be facing a “horrific” animal welfare problem due to the live export ban on cattle.

“The stance on live export will lead to horrific cruelty in Australia,” Gehan Jayawardhana said.

Mr Jayawardhana, who has spent 22 years as a research vet specialising in cattle production with the NT Department of Primary Industry and Fisheries, has led a project looking at the relationship between stocking rate, number of weaning musters and cow death rate in the Victoria River District.

“The data from this project allows the quantification of the number of extra cows that will die per year if live export to Indonesia is banned and properties are unable to muster, supplement or turn off stock due to lowered income,” he said.

The vet said data showed that in a population of 2.5 million cows 250,000 cows and most of their calves would die “under horrific conditions” and the export ban would lead to “reduced welfare for the survivors and significant rangeland degradation”.

“In my opinion live export is vital for animal welfare in north Australia as large numbers of cows and calves starving to death causes far worse cruelty than that occurring in a minority of Indonesian abattoirs as shown on 4 Corners,” he said.

Member for Katherine, Willem Westra van Holthe said the cattle crisis was “far from being over”. The worst is yet to come. We will see cattle starving or being shot and cattlemen going to the wall,” he said.

“There will be a significant impact on the NT economy and I am worried about the welfare of our cattlemen and their families.

“We've seen the rate of rural suicides rise drastically down south due to hardship. I fear the same here.

“Cattlemen will do it hard between now and next April, which is when they could expect their first shipments out after the Wet. In the meantime, overstocking will lead to overgrazing and a new season of calves are due to be born soon, adding to the problem.”

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The ban will only result in a "“horrific” animal welfare problem" IF the pastoralists take no action.

These farmers expect to be able to let the animals face whatever befalls them regardless of the animal welfare legal obligations these people have as owners.

It is unacceptable to even suggest such a stupid concept.

The pastoralists have made money hand over fist out of the misery of animals. Now they are expected to ensure there is no suffering in any way shape or form.

Did they not have contingency plans to ensure the welfare of their cattle should difficult times occur?


Posted by Animal cruelty unacceptable, 27/07/2011 10:19:32 AM, on Katherine Times
Being shot is better than facing the horrific conditions in Indonesian slaughterhouses.

The article is about the losses of pastoralists because there is no crisis in shooting the animals so long as it is done according to the law.

The fear mongering is that farmers are not making the money they once were. Aust isnt interested. What we expect is the cattle are either slaughtered here or shot. Pastoralists people dont seem to understand its not about them.

If cattle starve, then those responsible should face cruelty prosecution.

Posted by Ban live export permanently, 27/07/2011 10:46:31 AM, on Katherine Times
And this dropkick wouldn;t have a conflict of interest, would he? Anyone who lets an animal starve (especially after the massive taxpayer handouts) should be proseucted to the full extent of the law. And far better to shoot them here than get them on the rustbuckets sailing to the torture chambers in overseas countries. What is the mosdt appalling thing of all is that the government LISTENS to these whining dropkicks
Posted by Alexandra, 27/07/2011 2:24:21 PM, on Katherine Times
Alexandria,

"dropkick", wouldn:t" (sic)"massive taxpayer handouts", "proseucted"(sic), "better to shoot them here", "rustbuckets" torture chambers", "whining dropkicks" - I think you win todays prize of Animal Activist Bingo for the poorest spelling and most inaccurate use of you religion's "key-word list for derogatory terms and non-facts". You only failed to mention your qualifications and experience that allows you to offer such an eloquent response to a person who not only had a degree in Veterinary science but 20 years of relevant experience. Solutions are simple for the ignorant.

Posted by savannan, 27/07/2011 4:03:12 PM, on Katherine Times
Where's this money we're making hand over fist. While I was living on dirt floors and using an outside loo, I sure could have used it. Now upgraded to an old donga and still working every hour I can stand up, I would love to have this money. Please give me a massive taxpayer handout. I need it to feed poddies - the calves Gehan is speaking about. 500 at $.5 a day for 90 days is more money than given. Now what about water and feeding mum?

And what you don't seem to realize most of the cows die out in the bush over 2 days getting picked to death by crows +eaten by other cows while alive

Posted by Jen from the bush, 27/07/2011 5:18:29 PM, on Katherine Times
I cant get a shooting pit big enough and so if I leave them in the paddock the others will eat the dead carcasses to try and get protein into their systems and then they will have increased risks of Botulism and bones stuck in mouthes and it takes about 2 weeks to die - you rarely find them fast enough to save them.

You dont have contingency plans for kneejerk government idiocy. If there is NO moneyin our business, there is NO money for the cattle. And without any doubt, most funds we make are spent on the cattle with vaccines, parasite treatments, mineral supplements, water costs etc.

Posted by mouse, 30/07/2011 12:43:38 PM, on Katherine Times
Dear Savannan, I do apologise for a faulty keyboard at the location from which that post was sent.. My qualifications are at post-graduate level and include a Masters degree and Law. So I really have been reasonably eloquent upon occasion, but dealing with you people is not one of them. From the posts here, it is evident that pastoralists either have far more cattle than they can adquately care for (greed motive) and are clueless about the notion of contingency planning. People lose their jobs/income all the time and get the dole - no more, no less. Government policy changes. Get used to it.
Posted by Alexandra, 30/07/2011 7:16:02 PM, on Katherine Times
What an attitude! Alexandra re: '' People lose their jobs/income all the time and get the DOLE....Get use to it " I am not a farmer nor I have a law degree but I do know that what you offered wasn't a solution but an insult to a lot of good people. I don't believe what you said your qualification are, you re more likely a dole bludger.
Posted by Miranda, 30/07/2011 11:33:49 PM, on Katherine Times
Miranda, believe what you will. Your ignorance is apparent, and why is it up to the community to offer solutions to people to stop them abusing animals? Did they care about the 40,000 meatworkers who LOST THEIR JOBS as a direct result of this trade? All they got was the dole. Decent, hardworking Australians are deeply ashamed of these people who KNOWINGLY send their animals off to torture, and bitterly resentful that OUR taxes are being used to compensate people just because they had a brief interruption in their animal abuse. Their hold over the government may have to do with donations given.
Posted by Alexandra, 31/07/2011 5:05:04 PM, on Katherine Times

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES

Most popular articles




Katherine Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...